What Is Shadow IT? The Risks, Costs & Benefits Your Business Needs to Know
There are over 30,000 SaaS solutions on the market today. If one of your employees has a problem, there’s probably an app that can solve it. And since you can’t possibly offer your employees every technological option available, it’s more than likely that there’s one they’re eyeing that you don’t currently have in your stack. In fact they might already be using it.
Which raises a fair question: if it makes them more productive, what’s the harm?
While the intentions behind this are usually fine, the security risks it creates for your business are not. This unapproved tech being used inside your organization is what’s called shadow IT. And in this blog we’ll help you understand why it poses a significant risk by diving into:
- Why shadow IT is a serious problem for your cybersecurity and your bottom line
- How to help your employees understand the risks
- How to take back control and manage it going forward
But first, let’s get clear on what shadow IT actually is and what it looks like in the real world.
What Is Shadow IT?
Shadow IT is any software, app, device, or cloud service an employee uses for business purposes without the approval or knowledge of your IT department.
These are tools your employees start using on their own, and never get vetted by your IT department. They just show up on your network because someone found something they liked better, or needed to move faster than the approval process allowed.
Common Examples of Shadow IT
Shadow IT can take a lot of forms. Some of the most common include:
- Personal cloud storage like Google Drive or Dropbox used for file sharing
- Messaging apps like WhatsApp or iMessage used for work conversations
- Free SaaS applications or AI tools employees sign up for on their own
- Personal laptops or mobile devices connecting to your corporate network
- Personal email accounts used for work correspondence
If your IT department didn’t approve it, it’s shadow IT.
The Risks of Shadow IT
Shadow IT rarely causes problems all at once. It goes unchecked and undiscovered until something causes problems. Here’s what that typically looks like:
Cybersecurity Threats You Can’t See
As a general rule, every solution or device used within your organization should be vetted by your IT team. But if an employee is using something your IT department is unaware of, they obviously can’t enforce those requirements. Your security teams can’t patch software they don’t know exists. They can’t enforce security protocols on devices they’ve never touched. And they can’t run threat detection on tools that are completely off their radar.
The result is serious security gaps that expose you to potentially devastating consequences you aren’t even aware of.
Data Loss and Data Leaks
When employees use unauthorized tools for work, your company data goes with them. It gets stored on platforms your IT team doesn’t control, shared through channels they can’t monitor, and handled in ways that were never approved. That’s how sensitive data ends up exposed and how data breaches happen. The ramifications can be significant. For instance, sharing client sensitive data via an employee’s personal Dropbox can later get hacked causing significant financial and reputational damage to your business.
And if you haven’t addressed this in any meaningful way, chances are your employees have no idea they’re putting corporate data at risk.
Compliance Issues and Regulatory Risk
Depending on your industry, your business may be required to meet specific data protection standards. Regulations like the General Data Protection Regulation and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act have strict rules around where data is stored and who can access it. Shadow cloud services and unapproved applications make it nearly impossible to guarantee compliance, and the penalties for violations can be significant.
Imagine getting fined or losing compliance because of an unauthorized device you didn’t even know someone was using.
Hidden Costs That Add Up
Shadow IT has a financial cost most business leaders don’t see coming. Employees signing up for SaaS solutions on their own leads to duplicate subscriptions, wasted licenses, and budget bleed nobody is tracking. You can’t consolidate or negotiate what you don’t know about. Over time these system inefficiencies add up.
Operational Chaos
When different teams are using different unauthorized tools, nothing integrates cleanly. Data gets siloed. Workflows break down. And when something goes wrong, your IT team has to untangle a web of shadow IT assets they were never meant to manage in the first place.
The Benefits of Shadow IT
If you discover shadow IT in your business, your first instinct might be to shut it down. But before you do, it’s worth asking why it’s there. In fact, 80% of IT professionals say their company should embrace new technology employees request.
Here are a few wins you can take from discovering shadow IT you find in your organization:
It Exposes Gaps in Your Current Tech Stack
When employees go around your approved tools and approved software, they’re telling you those tools aren’t cutting it. That’s valuable intelligence. Instead of guessing where your cloud infrastructure is falling short, shadow IT shows you exactly where the gaps are and what your team actually needs to do their jobs better.
It Empowers Your Employees
Employees who feel like they have a say in the tools they use are more engaged and more productive. Shadow IT, frustrating as it is, reflects people who care enough to find better ways to work. If you respond to it by opening up a real approval process for requesting and vetting new cloud based applications and SaaS solutions, you turn that instinct into an asset.
It Can Save You Money
This one surprises most business leaders. If employees are consistently finding free or low cost tools that do the job better than what you’re paying for, that’s worth knowing. Discovering shadow IT gives you the chance to audit your current IT assets, cut what isn’t working, and invest in approved tools your team will actually use.
How to Manage Shadow IT
If you’ve discovered shadow IT within your organization the goal is not to make your employees feel like suspects. Your aim should be to build a system that gives your team flexibility while giving your IT department the visibility and control they need to keep your business secure. To begin:
Start with a Software Audit
Before you can control shadow IT, you need to identify it. That means taking a hard look at everything that’s actually running on your network. A thorough audit will surface:
- Shadow IT applications and unauthorized tools employees are actively using
- Unmanaged devices connecting to your corporate network
- Cloud based services and SaaS applications your IT team never approved
This shouldn’t be treated as a one-time exercise. Businesses should run quarterly SaaS discovery reports to identify newly adopted applications, duplicate subscriptions, and unauthorized cloud services before they create security or compliance risks.
Tools like cloud access security brokers (CASB) such as Microsoft Defender for Cloud Apps can help your IT team maintain visibility across your network, monitor risky activity, and detect unauthorized cloud applications as employees adopt new tools over time.
Educate Your Employees on the Risks
Once you know what’s on your network, the next step is making sure your employees understand why it matters. Most aren’t trying to create security gaps. They just don’t know they are. That’s a training problem, not a discipline problem.
Explain what shadow IT is, why it creates serious security risks, and what the consequences can be for your business. But just as important as explaining the problem is giving them somewhere to go with it. Let them know that if there’s a tool they love or a problem they need solved, there’s a process for that.
Build a Clear Process for Requesting Approved Tools
One of the main reasons employees turn to shadow IT is that the approval process for getting new tools is too slow or too complicated. If going through IT feels like filing a formal complaint, people will find a workaround. Build a simple, straightforward process that makes it easy for employees to request new SaaS applications or cloud based tools. The easier you make it to ask, the less likely they are to go around you.
Vet Every Tool Before It Goes Live
Every new tool that enters your corporate environment should go through a consistent vetting process. Before anything gets approved, ask:
- Do you actually need it?
- Do you already have approved software that does the same thing?
- Does it meet your security protocols and compliance requirements?
This is where cloud access security brokers and your IT team earn their keep, evaluating new cloud services for compatibility with your existing IT infrastructure before they ever touch your network.
Set Clear Rules and Stick to Them
Once your employees understand the risks and have a process for requesting new tools, you need a formal set of rules that governs how technology is used across your organization.
That means defining:
- Which personal devices are permitted to connect to your corporate network and under what conditions
- Multi factor authentication requirements for accessing company data and cloud based applications
- Conditional access policies and device compliance standards to control which users and devices can access company systems
- Rules around personal accounts and personal email accounts being used for business purposes
- Where company data can and cannot be stored
A policy nobody enforces is just a suggestion. Make sure your IT team has the access management tools in place to back it up, and revisit it regularly as new cloud based services and SaaS solutions enter the market.
Work with a Managed Service Provider (MSP)
Even with the right policies in place, maintaining complete visibility across your network is a full time job. For most small and mid-sized businesses, your internal IT team is already stretched thin. And shadow IT doesn’t wait for a convenient time to become a problem.
This is where a managed service provider comes in. An MSP is an external IT partner that manages and monitors your technology environment on your behalf. It’s like having a dedicated IT department without the overhead of building one in house.
But not all MSPs are created equal. The right partner won’t just be a reactive responder. They act as a strategic partner and build everything we just walked you through — the audit, the employee education, the approval process, the vetting, the policy, the monitoring — specifically to fit your business.
That’s how we work with our clients. Rather than waiting for something to go wrong, we continuously work with you to build the kind of IT infrastructure that supports your business as it grows. We help you develop approval processes, vet new tools, enforce security protocols, and stay ahead of compliance requirements.
If shadow IT is something you’ve been putting off dealing with, reach out to Lenny Giller at lenny@reliabletechnology.co and let’s start the conversation.